Andy Kelly/Current timeline

Andy Kelly is what would be considered as a quintessential nice guy. She is Becca Brady's childhood friend.

Early life
Andy and Becca grew up together, what with their parents being very close. Andy has always been infatuated with Becca since they were kids; a particularly good memory he often cites is that of them jumping off the end of the dock at Spring Lake.

At one point, Becca and her best friend Lolly set him up with a temp at Becca's working place, Melanie. Eventually, the couple moved in together.

Becca
"Andy: She thinks I have feelings for you. Becca: Just tell her you don't. Andy: I don't want to lie to her."

- Andy and Becca talking about Melanie

Andy and Melanie attended Becca's wedding to her Sean. However, since this Becca has "time-traveled" from 2014/5 and knows that not only will she and Sean separate in the future, but that she and Andy will get engaged, Becca breaks it off. He witnesses Becca, and Lolly, running away from Sean at the altar. When Becca arrives on his doorstep the next day to return the wedding gift he got her (a framed photo of them as children on the docks, though Andy claims that the frame was the intended gift), Becca kissed him, much to his surprise. Melanie seems to have seen them, and Andy tells her anyway. A few days later, Andy goes to Becca and Lolly's apartment and kisses Becca.

Feeling guilty, he tells his current girlfriend, Melanie, about both encounters. Despite this, he continues flirting with Becca at Grumpy Rick's annual Halloween party when his plans with Melanie fall through. At the party, Melanie sees them together and assumes the worst; the same goes for Becca's ex Sean who punches him and causes a scene. Andy is unable to deny his feelings and eventually admits them to Becca, who instead sends him mixed signals and tells him to fix things with Melanie.

After Jamie tries to mend the bridge between Andy and Sean, Andy and Melanie's, as well as his and Sean's, fight only gets worse. He goes home drunk without Melanie, who insists on staying at her parents'. The next day, Becca calls him and tells him to meet her at the house in Spring Lake where they used to spend their time as kids. He confronts her about being unsure of how she feels about him; nonetheless, Becca tells him that she will take his arrival as a sign. On the way to her, while on the New Jersey Turnpike, Andy's car gets hit by a truck and he is rushed to the hospital.