Andy Kelly/Original timeline

"Andy was the opposite of my first husband, Sean, in every way. He was sweet, kind, responsible, had a job, brought me home Indian food before I even realized how much I wanted Indian food. But did he set me on fire? Well, I was warm."

- Becca's voiceover

Andy Kelly is what would be considered as a quintessential nice guy. She is Becca Brady's childhood friend and fiancé.

History
Andy and his girlfriend Melanie attended Becca's wedding to her first husband, Sean. As a wedding present, Andy gave them a picture frame with a photo of him and Becca as children on the docks. However, Sean had Becca return the frame to the store, and she never saw the picture. Eventually, Melanie left Andy.

Engaged
"Non-blood-related, super nice Andy Kelly. I know he was dorky, but he got cute."

- Becca telling Lolly about Andy

At one point, Andy and Becca became engaged. They were together for four years. Unbeknownst to him, Becca was having second thoughts about their impending union the day before their wedding.